This image of a pensive man seated beside a stream, flower in hand, was commissioned by James R. Osgood Co. for the periodical, Poets and Etchers, to illustrate Ralph Waldo Emerson's "The Apology", along with two other vignettes. Despite the despondant mood of the piece, it is beautifully executed and was printed in a rich black ink with a touch of mahogany, softening the image against the cream paper.
Withoff notes in the catalogue raisonne: "Smillie designed these illustrations at the happiest time of his life. He and his bride [Annie] were spending a month in Montrose, Pa., and Annie assisted him by gathering flowers for his drawings and posing for female figures."